Police Chief Raises Rifle Specter
Indian Shores’ top cop suggests long guns are appearing at beach town meetings, then concedes no known incidents.
REDINGTON SHORES — “This is not meant to be scary.”
It was two weeks until Halloween, and Indian Shores Police Chief Lee Ann Holroyd stood before the Town Commission, sharing information from a meeting of police chiefs she had attended that morning.
The ominous message: Carrying a rifle into a public meeting is not illegal.
“We as officers may be faced with — and you may be faced with — a person armed with a long gun attending our meetings,” she told commissioners Oct. 14.
Holroyd went further, suggesting the scenario was already playing out.
“This is happening in some of our beach communities where there are people that are coming to public meetings,” said Holroyd, whose department contracts with Redington Shores for law enforcement. “And as I know I’ve discussed here before, long guns are permitted at public meetings at this time.”
Toward the end of her warning, which lasted about three minutes and drew no questions or discussion from commissioners, Holroyd repeated: “Some of the small beach towns have been experiencing this.”
But it turns out that warning was far more alarming than the reality.
When asked later by The Pinellas Current where and when those incidents occurred, Holroyd conceded she was unaware of any actual incidents involving people carrying long guns into public meetings.
“There were no specific incidents or locations that I was made aware of,” she said via email. “The discussion involved the possibility of individuals [with long guns] attending smaller, barrier island, public meetings.”
The chief said her purpose was to educate commissioners about what she described as a "gap" in state law and prepare them for possible encounters that could affect public safety.
A legal loophole?
Holroyd’s warning stems from a 2025 Florida appeals court ruling that struck down the state's longstanding prohibition on openly carrying firearms.
The First District Court of Appeal held that Florida's general ban on open carry violated the Second Amendment.
But the ruling also brought renewed attention to an apparent loophole in state law governing where firearms may be carried. Because the statute specifically mentions handguns, people may be able to openly carry long guns — including rifles and shotguns — into places where handguns remain prohibited.
“Some people don't believe it's a gap,” Holroyd said. “I personally, as a law enforcement officer, believe there's a bit of a gap.”
The Florida Police Chiefs Association shares that position.
The group warned that recent court decisions had created loopholes allowing long guns in places where handguns are off limits. It supported two bills during the 2026 legislative session aimed at clarifying that firearms restrictions apply regardless of the type of weapon being carried. Both died in committee.
“Leaving this issue unresolved could place unnecessary strain on law enforcement, increase security costs, and create fear and confusion in our communities,” wrote state Rep. Christine Hunschofsky, D-Parkland, in explaining online why she filed the House bill.
Preparing for the possibility
Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri also raised concerns following the ruling.
“Our position is that sensitive spaces must be respected, so we're going to take the necessary action to ensure that that intent is carried out,” Gualtieri told the News Service of Florida last year.
But the sheriff's office, which provides law enforcement services to several beach communities, said it was unaware of any incidents involving people carrying long guns into public meetings.
“We are not aware of any situations where that has occurred and we follow applicable law,” Sgt. Jessica Mackesy wrote in a Nov. 5 email.
Several Pinellas beach mayors did not respond to questions about whether their municipalities had received legal guidance on the issue or discussed security measures or contingency plans.
At the Redington Shores meeting, Holroyd told commissioners that officers would monitor anyone carrying a rifle or other long gun into a meeting.
If the weapon were handled unsafely or in a threatening manner, she said, officers would intervene. Otherwise, she said, the person would be allowed to remain.
Holroyd also described a discussion among police chiefs about whether officials should end a public meeting if someone arrived carrying a rifle.
“One of the chiefs said, ‘I think my counsel would say we’re going to end the meeting,’ ” she said. “I don't know that that's strongly advised, but your attorney can advise you on that.”
She acknowledged that the presence of someone carrying a rifle could alarm elected officials and residents, but stressed that officers must respect constitutional rights.
“There may be a shock factor involved, but please know that if you're looking at us pleadingly, we're going to be doing what we can do legally,” she said.
Other communities have responded differently since the appeals court ruling.
At Belleair Bluffs City Hall, a signboard warns that any firearm is prohibited during City Commission meetings, whether carried openly or concealed. Anyone carrying a firearm will be asked to leave, according to the sign, which cites Florida Statutes 790.06 and 790.10.
The sign also displays a copy of Attorney General James Uthmeier's September 2025 guidance on the open-carry ruling. The memorandum says the ruling did not invalidate restrictions on carrying firearms in certain locations, but it does not specifically address whether those restrictions apply to openly carried rifles and shotguns at public meetings.
Belleair Bluffs officials did not respond to questions about the sign, including what legal authority the city would rely on to enforce the ban against long guns.
Meanwhile, the Sarasota Police Department stationed officers equipped with long guns inside City Commission chambers following last year's ruling, said police spokeswoman Genevieve Judge.
"We continue to assess staffing and security needs based on the circumstances of each meeting," Judge said. "Our priority remains providing a safe environment for commissioners, city staff and members of the public."
No incidents, no records
While Holroyd said she knew of no incidents involving rifles at public meetings, she pointed to a separate encounter involving someone openly carrying a long gun.
She described a recent social media post showing a woman carrying an AR-style rifle while walking her dog on the beach. Officers responded to a complaint about the dog being off its leash, she said, but the firearm itself was legally carried.
The chief reiterated that her warning about public meetings was intended as a precaution.
“At times, there are citizens, well within their rights, that wish to test law enforcement and public officials,” she wrote. “These understandable actions prompted me to make another point of education to the Commission in Redington Shores and to remind them of the legality of carrying at a public meeting.”
Initially, The Pinellas Current made a public records request to the Indian Shores Police Department for any records concerning long guns at public meetings. Nadine Esposito, Holroyd’s executive assistant, first referred the newspaper to Redington Shores and later to the incident involving the rifle-toting woman. She did not respond to an email asking whether the department possessed any of the requested records.
Holroyd subsequently confirmed that the department had searched its records and found none, stating “there are no records responsive to your request.”