Who Watches Largo's Watchers?
Police acknowledge unanswered questions about outside agencies' access to data collected by the city's Flock license plate cameras.
LARGO — Could officers from other law enforcement agencies improperly access the city's license plate data without being detected? What about employees of Flock Safety, the company that runs the surveillance system? And how many privately owned Flock cameras operate in Largo?
Those were among the questions city commissioners fired off during a more than hour-long presentation Nov. 10 on the police department's automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, a technology that has drawn growing scrutiny here and elsewhere.
Police officials said 189 Florida law enforcement agencies and one federal agency — the Office of Inspector General — have access to information collected by Largo's cameras. The department, in turn, can search records shared by more than 210 organizations nationwide.
Largo operates three Flock cameras and retains the information they collect for one year — more than 50 times longer than the seven-day retention period now recommended by Flock Safety.
The company announced the change from its previous 30-day default retention period in August amid growing national controversy, though existing customers can maintain their current retention policies. Flock also introduced new safeguards to detect improper searches and allow investigators to preserve records for active cases.
Police acknowledged they could not immediately answer whether the department could detect improper searches by other agencies.
Recent incidents involving law enforcement officers — including three Pinellas County sheriff's deputies — accused of using ALPRs to track romantic interests, former partners and others have heightened public concerns about how the data can be misused. The high-speed cameras, which use artificial intelligence, also have drawn criticism following incidents elsewhere in which inaccurate license plate information led to wrongful police stops, arrests and detentions.
“Can we tell if somebody's misusing our system from the outside, like doing multiple searches on somebody?” asked Commissioner Mike DiBrizzi.
Sgt. Christopher Keeler asked whether he meant hackers.
“No, just somebody using it to track their girlfriend, you know, or whatever, using our system,” DiBrizzi said.
“Honestly, I do not know the answer to that,” Keeler said. "That is something that I probably have to kind of table and get back to that. That is a very good question."
Keeler said that officers from other agencies must enter a case or event number and a reason when searching Largo's records. He said the department can identify who accessed its records but does not audit outside searches performed by other agencies.
Commissioner John Lauser raised concerns about whether Flock employees could search the city's license plate data without being subject to the same safeguards as police officers.
“They can search for a tag and they’re not held to the same standards as a law enforcement officer,” he said. “Do we know who at Flock has access to the data?”
“I would have to get back to you on that and get those answers for you, sir,” Keeler said.
The department conducts monthly audits and random reviews of its officers' searches, Keeler said. Flock also provides automated tools that flag unusual activity, including repeated searches for the same license plate.
Keeler said the department has identified no improper searches by Largo officers since it began using the technology in 2021.
The city's three Flock cameras are not used for immigration enforcement, Keeler said, although a Largo officer assigned to a Drug Enforcement Administration task force searches the data for federal narcotics investigations. The officer's searches have appeared in the department's random audits, but police said they involved local drug cases only.
Police Chief Mike Loux credited the department's ethical standards, policies and oversight procedures for its record of no misuse of Flock data by his officers. He noted that officers "have access to so many databases we can find out pretty much anything about anybody that we wanted to."
Those accused of using the system for unofficial or personal reasons "made a bad personal choice," said Lt. Ryan Dulski.
"That was illegal and they're paying for that criminally," he said. "I think now that it's out there, I don't think that you're going to see much misuse. And if they do, it's going to be caught."
Commissioners, who were generally supportive of the program, also asked about privately owned Flock cameras, such as those used by businesses including Home Depot, Lowe's and RaceTrac.
Police said participating businesses share information that officers can search, including license plates, vehicle descriptions and the times vehicles were observed. The same search requirements apply to privately owned cameras.
Officials could not immediately say how many such cameras operate in Largo.
The city's cameras include two installed along East Bay Drive in 2021 and a third added near the Horizon West Bay/City Hall parking garage last year to help protect city commissioners and residents, Keeler said.
The East Bay Drive cameras are temporarily out of service following Gov. Ron DeSantis' directive in August to remove Flock cameras from state roads. Police estimated that more than 10,000 cameras statewide were affected by the order. Largo's cameras will be reinstalled outside the affected areas, police said.
The "Falcon" cameras photograph passing vehicles and record license plates, vehicle characteristics, locations and times. They do not provide live video feeds.
Largo pays roughly $9,800 annually for the three cameras, including extended data storage for each.
Police credited the technology with helping solve major crimes, including a homicide and a recent bank robbery on East Bay Drive.
“I think it’s a valuable tool for our law enforcement,” City Manager John Curp said. “It’s a good program.”
Commissioners on Nov. 17 are expected to consider an agreement with the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, which has been designated as Flock Safety's lead agency in Florida for transmitting license plate information through state and national law enforcement databases. Police said the administrative change would not affect Largo's ownership of its license plate data or its existing camera operations.
The broader controversy surrounding the technology could nevertheless draw public attention.
"I imagine we're going to have quite the crowd here when this comes up," DiBrizzi said.