Halloween concert moved after city sued to stop it
A judge issued an injunction hours after the event was relocated to a nearby country club.
SEMINOLE — The planned Halloween weekend bash that created such a stir among city officials was relocated hours before a judge issued an injunction blocking a couple from holding live music events at their waterfront home.
The temporary injunction, issued by Circuit Judge Evan G. Frayman on Oct. 30, barred Scott and Judy McGehee from holding concerts at their Baywood Park Drive home, including events scheduled for Oct. 30 and 31.
City officials said the gatherings could pose public safety risks, particularly with youngsters out trick-or-treating in the upscale neighborhood.
The judge also ordered the McGehees to halt any further unpermitted construction. The restrictions will stay in place until further court order.
The city sought the injunction before receiving formal City Council approval, a move that the city attorney said will require council action after the fact. The judge granted the request without first hearing from the McGehees, finding that immediate harm could occur if the court did not act.
Photographs and video posted on Facebook by Scott McGehee show that at least one concert went ahead at nearby Seminole Lake Country Club.
The city filed suit Oct. 29, two days after a City Council meeting where a former council member raised concerns about the events.
In a Facebook post, McGehee blamed the controversy on a neighbor.
"We had an issue recently, where one of the neighbors created havoc with the city and our home," he wrote. "She spread a number of rumors that the city had to check out. We certainly understand the cities concern based on the information they were given."
The post stated that the evening's entertainment would feature country music artists Will Dempsey and Fiona Joy and that additional musicians would perform in a music bingo event.
"Nothing has really changed except for the scenery," McGehee wrote.
It was unclear whether the Oct. 31 concert — billed as the "Halloween Bash at the Bayou" and featuring Chad Big Country — also took place at the country club.
At the Oct. 27 meeting, former Councilor Roger Edelman warned that the gathering could overwhelm narrow neighborhood streets, with cars parked along the roads while costumed kids go door-to-door. He urged additional Pinellas County Sheriff's Office patrols to protect residents and children.
He said previous concerts at the property had drawn as many as 200 people. Mayor Leslie Waters also voiced concern about the safety of youngsters amid the additional traffic expected from the concerts.
The council took no formal action at the meeting, but City Manager Ann Toney-Deal said officials were coordinating with code enforcement, the building official, fire officials and the sheriff's office.
Asked what authority the city relied on to bring the lawsuit without a council vote, City Attorney Jay Daigneault told The Pinellas Current that he consulted individually with council members Oct. 29, before the suit was filed.
"The suit was filed following my individual consultations with Council members on Thursday, which were prompted by additional information obtained following the October 27 meeting," he said in an email. "The filing will be subject to the Council's ratification at its next business meeting."
The city charter authorizes the city attorney to prosecute and defend lawsuits when required by the council, but does not explicitly require advance approval by formal vote.
In his order, the judge found that the use of the property as a concert venue went against its residential zoning restrictions. The order also cited unpermitted electrical work and fire safety concerns involving large crowds.
Daigneault said the city issued a stop-work order before requesting the injunction because construction was occurring at the home without a building permit.
Meanwhile, all was quiet at the McGehees' property on Halloween night, according to sheriff's office records.
Deputies conducted three patrols on Halloween night, at 7:29 p.m., 9:49 p.m. and 10:38 p.m. None of the patrol reports documented disturbances or enforcement actions.