Seminole sues to stop Halloween bash
City seeks emergency injunction against homeowners, alleging illegal concerts and unpermitted electrical work at waterfront home.
SEMINOLE — Citing public safety concerns, the city has sued a homeowner and his wife over a Halloween bash expected to draw hundreds to their quiet waterfront neighborhood, a marked escalation of an issue raised at a City Council meeting earlier in the week.
The seven-page lawsuit, filed Oct. 29 in Pinellas circuit court, alleges Scott and Judy McGehee, 9049 Baywood Park Dr., illegally turned their home overlooking Cross Bayou into a concert venue and performed electrical work without required permits.
In an emergency motion, the city asked a judge to issue a temporary injunction halting events scheduled for Oct. 30 and 31, when youngsters will be trick or treating through the neighborhood.
The city also wants to prevent future concerts at the property, which has been promoted as a private music venue called "Live on the Bayou." The complaint cites social media advertisements promoting performances by country music artists Will Dempsey and Chad Big Country.
A check of online court records Oct. 31 showed no ruling on the requested injunction, and it was unclear whether either event took place. The case was assigned to Circuit Judge Evan Frayman. A message sent to Scott McGehee through his Facebook account went unanswered.
According to the complaint, the events have drawn or are expected to draw between 100 and 300 people. The city contends that operating a concert venue violates the property's residential zoning restrictions.
Seminole also alleges that electrical work was performed without permits despite a stop-work order. It warned that the events could create fire hazards, traffic problems and crowd-control issues, particularly during Halloween.
"The proposed Events scheduled for October 30 and 31 constitute an additional safety hazard as the Events are proposed to be held in a residential neighborhood during the Halloween holiday which is reasonably expected to result in significantly more traffic in the residential neighborhood while children are outdoors and walking the residential neighborhood in celebration of Halloween," the complaint reads.
"Further, the neighborhood where the Subject Property is located has historically attracted many children from outside the neighborhood for purposes of trick-or treating, substantially increasing the number of children, parents, and children in the neighborhood," it reads.
The city argues that the anticipated crowds could change the home's occupancy classification under National Fire Protection Association standards, potentially creating a fire hazard for attendees and nearby residents.
The lawsuit was filed after Roger Edelman, a former city councilor and resident of nearby Seminole Lake Country Club Estates, warned the City Council Oct. 27 that the gathering could overwhelm the neighborhood's narrow streets.
“There are a lot of places to hold it besides on your backyard in a residential community,” he said.
Edelman said the event had grown over the years and that the organizer had advertised parking at Seminole Lake Country Club, 6100 Augusta Blvd., without permission. He said the club planned to prohibit event parking on its property.
“So we do not know where all these cars are going to go on the street,” he said.
Edelman suggested Pinellas County Sheriff's Office patrols "for the protection of our kids and protection of the neighborhood.”
City Manager Ann Toney-Deal, who signed the city's complaint, told council members that officials had learned of the situation earlier in the week. She said the city was coordinating with code enforcement, the building official, the interim fire chief and the sheriff's office.
"It's concerning," Mayor Leslie Waters said. "You've got hundreds of trick-or-treaters coming through the neighborhood. The young kids are running around like crazy, and it's all the parents can do to keep them on the sidewalk."
Beyond stopping the concerts, the city is asking the court to prohibit further construction without permits and authorize it, under the terms of an injunction, to enter the property to address nonconforming uses.