Public Emergency, Private Gain
Belleair Shore used hurricane emergency powers to approve mayor's generator variance
BELLEAIR SHORE — Three inches.
That’s what the mayor of this tiny and tony beach town required to install a whole-house generator beside his garage. The back-to-back hurricanes had already passed. And while Stephen Blume joked that he didn't need the gas-powered device anymore, his fellow commissioners used the town’s emergency powers to forgo the standard public hearing and grant his zoning variance.
That October 2024 vote — taken with barely a quorum in a conference room outside of town — came after the town attorney cited a Florida law allowing local governments to waive legal procedures during declared emergencies for the “performance of public work.”
More than two years later, questions remain about whether Belleair Shore — a mile-long enclave of some 55 beachfront homes about four miles south of Clearwater — properly applied emergency authority to the mayor's routine variance request and whether Blume complied with state voting-conflict requirements.
More broadly, the episode illuminates how Florida's emergency management laws can be applied in ways that benefit private individuals.
"The situation just doesn't pass the smell test," said Ben Wilcox, research director for Integrity Florida, a nonpartisan government watchdog group based in Tallahassee.
"It seems like this is an improvement the mayor is making to his own private home," he said. "I don't see how it could be considered public work."
Blume did not respond to emailed questions about whether he voted on his own variance request — something the official records don't answer — and why he waited more than 19 months after the vote to publicly disclose a voting conflict.
Approached after a Town Commission meeting last month, Blume maintained that he had abstained from voting, although an abstention is not documented in meeting minutes or the audio recording.
“I'm sure I didn't vote on it,” Blume said. “Because my attorney would have told me I had to exclude myself even if I forgot.”
Normally, variance hearings are quasi-judicial, or court-like, proceedings in which public officials act more like judges than policymakers. Hearings are publicly advertised, testimony is taken under oath and decisions are based on evidence, findings of fact and zoning regulations.
Under Florida law, elected local officials with a voting conflict must publicly disclose the nature of that conflict before the vote, abstain and file a Memorandum of Voting Conflict, known as Form 8B, within 15 days.
Unlike appointed officials, however, they are not prohibited from participating in discussion after disclosing the conflict. Violations can result in fines of up to $10,000, suspension or removal from office.
Conflict Questions Remain
The Pinellas Current began investigating the variance vote last spring. On May 22, the publication requested a recording of the Oct. 15, 2024 Town Commission meeting from Town Clerk Mary Palmer.
Asked a week later who voted on the variance request and whether Blume had filed a related Form 8B, Palmer eventually replied in a June 1 email: “the Form 8B was not filled out as the variance was approved during an State of Emergency due to the storms . As far as who voted the tape is not clear.”
The form Blume ultimately filled out and signed — dated June 2 — stated that the measure “inured to my special private gain or loss.” Blume listed Oct. 14, 2024, as the date of the vote in two places on the form, although town records show commissioners approved his variance on Oct. 15.
When asked whether anyone had advised him about the voting-conflict form before or after the vote, Blume said he wasn't sure.
“It could have been my attorney or her,” he said, referring to Palmer, who stood beside him in the same conference room where the variance was approved.
Palmer clarified to Blume that she had sent him the Form 8B and that he completed it on the date shown on the form, not the day of the 2024 meeting.
“Why do we have to dwell on it?” Palmer asked a reporter. “I don’t understand that.”
Blume, a mechanical contractor who became mayor in early 2024 after serving as vice mayor, apologized for not responding to questions emailed twice to his official and business addresses.
“I don’t think I did anything wrong,” he said. “If I did, there was no intention to do anything wrong. I don’t think I did, either.”
The town attorney, Daniel P. Lewis, declined to answer emailed questions about the vote, including the legal basis for treating the mayor's variance as “public work” and whether he advised Blume about his obligation to disclose a conflict of interest and abstain from voting.
“I am in receipt of your questions,” wrote Lewis, an attorney with the Persson, Cohen, Mooney, Fernandez & Jackson law firm, which has offices in Lakewood Ranch and Venice. “However, I have not been authorized to discuss town legal matters with anyone. Further, as you are not my client, I cannot provide you with legal analysis and guidance.”
Responding to a follow-up request for comment, Lewis reiterated that he was "not authorized to discuss town legal matters" or provide "legal authority, guidance, or analysis to non-clients."
Although the town clerk had suggested the town's emergency declaration was why Blume did not contemporaneously file a Form 8B, the director of the Florida Ethics Institute questioned whether the declaration could override state voting-conflict rules.
While state law grants localities broad emergency powers, it does not expressly authorize them to waive ethics requirements, said Caroline Klancke, a former senior attorney, general counsel and deputy executive director for the Florida Commission on Ethics.
“If the Legislature wanted to afford political subdivisions such power [it] could have easily done so,” she said, noting that lawmakers have created emergency exceptions to other ethics laws but not to the voting-conflict provisions.
Kerrie Stillman, the ethics commission's executive director, said the agency could find no advisory opinions addressing whether local governments may use emergency management powers to waive laws governing conflicts of interest in official votes.
As for Blume's case, Stillman stated that commission staff "cannot comment on the conduct of an official nor can we comment on the application of the law to an official."
The commission, which investigates alleged ethics violations by state and local public officials, has no public record of a complaint against Blume, according to Lynn Blais, Stillman’s assistant. Blais said the agency could neither confirm nor deny whether a complaint exists.
Blume’s variance was decided by voice vote rather than a roll call, meeting minutes show, thus leaving no official record of how each of the three commissioners present voted. At the time, two seats on the five-member commission were vacant.
After releasing Blume's late-filed Form 8B in response to a public records request, Palmer declined to answer further questions.
“I am not authorized to give official statements on town business,” she emailed.
Asked who was, she did not respond.
A Variance Resurfaces
The generator project, valued at $18,000, had been in the works well before Hurricanes Helene and Milton.
On Aug. 26, 2024, Palmer told Blume that the building official was not signing off on the generator permit because of setback issues. In an email copied to Lewis, she asked, “Do we have a process in place for variances?”
Later that day, she advised the contractor that a variance hearing would be required, along with a property survey, supporting documents and a $150 application fee. The contractor had sought relief from the town's 7.5-foot side setback requirement for an encroachment of about three inches.
In an Aug. 29 email, Blume asked Palmer to prepare a letter on town letterhead for the town attorney to sign, stating that the town had “no problem approving a variance” of about three inches for the generator installation.
Palmer replied: “Mayor, I am sorry but I cannot do the letter. Please call when you get a chance.”
The variance hearing was subsequently scheduled as a stand-alone agenda item for Oct. 7, 2024 — 11 days after Hurricane Helene made landfall in Florida's Big Bend region and two days before Hurricane Milton struck the Gulf Coast.
The day before the hearing, however, the mayor emailed Palmer to cancel it as Milton approached, records show.
At the Oct. 15 regular commission meeting, Blume brought up the variance as a non-agenda item during mayor and commissioner comments.
The meeting was held one day after Blume and Palmer signed a proclamation extending the town's state of local emergency for an additional seven days, a copy of the document shows. Under state law, local emergency declarations expire after seven days unless renewed.
According to the audio, Blume broached the subject by asking: "How about the generator variance? When are we going to get that done?"
"Well, we're going to have to . . ." Palmer began before the mayor interjected.
"I mean, why can't we do it now?" he asked.
"We could ask attorney Daniel, seeing that we had this storm as an emergency, can they just discuss and approve this?" Palmer replied.
Lewis asked whether the variance had been publicly noticed.
"It was posted and advertised, but not for this day," Palmer said.
As they awaited Lewis’ opinion, Blume, Vice Mayor Daniel Storie and Commissioner Michael Tolbert made small talk for about seven minutes while seated at the conference room table in Belleair Bluffs City Hall, about a mile away on the mainland. Belleair Shore has no Town Hall.
The three spoke about setbacks, flood zones and erosion from the storms. They also talked about their spouses while Palmer told them she would start putting away chairs.
"My wife keeps saying, 'Are you ever going to get that done?' " Blume said. "Well, we don't need it now. We already had the storm."
Tolbert — whose own zoning variance request for a home generator was approved in July 2025 under the town’s normal processes — then chimed in.
"Our 45th wedding anniversary was this past weekend," he said. "My wife told me that the standard 45th wedding anniversary gift is a whole-house generator."
"I have a contractor for you when you get ready," said Blume, adding that his workers "were ready to do it three months ago."
Calling It 'Public Work'
"Do you have an answer?" Palmer asked Lewis.
"This is the generator, correct?" Lewis asked. "What's the purpose of the generator?"
"Hurricane," Blume said.
Lewis then cited Section 252.38 of the Florida Statutes, which deals with emergency management powers of local governments, and said, “The town has the power and authority to waive procedures and formalities otherwise required by law pertaining to the performance of public work and taking whatever prudent action is necessary to ensure health, safety and welfare of the community.”
"There you go. Amen," Palmer said.
"Well, it's not like I'm going to put it in anytime soon," said Blume, who didn't install the generator at his 3,734-square-foot residence at 1260 Gulf Blvd. until several months later.
"I just remind you this is a public record. It is being recorded," Lewis said.
As commissioners prepared to vote, Lewis instructed them: "Under the local state of emergency proclamation, you're moving that it is a performance of public work to take whatever prudent action is necessary to ensure health, safety and welfare of the community."
Storie then moved to approve the variance and Tolbert seconded the motion. It passed unanimously by voice vote, according to the minutes.
"Thank you," Blume said.
The Reach of Emergency Powers
The generator permit was issued in April 2025, and the work passed a final inspection three months later, according to Pinellas County Building Department records. The applicant answered “No” when asked whether the installation was due to damage from Helene or Milton.
Whether a generator serving only the mayor's personal residence qualifies as "public work" under state law is unclear. The term is not specifically defined in the statute Lewis cited.
The nonprofit American Public Works Association defines public work as “the combination of physical assets, management practices, policies, and personnel necessary for government to provide and sustain structures and services essential to the welfare and acceptable quality of life for its citizens.”
The provision that was applied became part of Florida law in 1993, a year after Hurricane Andrew devastated South Florida.
It allows local governments to waive “procedures and formalities” for public work and seven other specified emergency activities, including contracting, incurring obligations, and appropriating or spending public funds.
It makes no mention of zoning variances.
"It seems like the mayor got the attorney to give him an opinion that allowed him to be able to get the variance based on the emergency situation," said Wilcox, of Integrity Florida.
"But I don't think this is going to look good to the public."
Documents
Aug. 29, 2024 — Mayor's Request for Variance Letter
Email exchange in which Mayor Stephen Blume asks the town clerk to prepare a letter for the town attorney to sign supporting his generator variance. The clerk declines.
1 page · 644 KB
October 2024 Town Commission meeting minutes
Official record of the commission's approval of the mayor's generator variance.
2 pages · 197 KB
2024 Florida Statutes, Section 252.38 — Emergency Powers (Highlighted Excerpt)
Emergency management law cited by the town attorney to justify approving the mayor's variance request. The relevant provision is highlighted.
2 pages · 81 KB
Mayor Stephen Blume's Form 8B, dated June 2, 2026
Mayor's voting-conflict disclosure, completed nearly 20 months after the variance approval.
2 pages · 873 KB