74°Mostly Sunny

Saint Petersburg, FL 

The Pinellas Current

Independent news for Pinellas County

Support us

A No-Win Situation

Facing public pressure, some Pinellas municipalities are scaling back efforts to inform residents about the property-tax measure's potential impact.

The Pinellas Current@pinellascurrent· Saint Petersburg, FLByCarlos Moncada
Competing campaigns over Amendment 3 have become the backdrop for disputes over how local governments inform residents about the measure's potential impact.Photo illustration/The Pinellas Current.

PINELLAS COUNTY — In Largo, a town hall intended to inform the public about Amendment 3 met with political backlash. Seminole removed links to position statements opposing the ballot measure from its website after accusations of electioneering surfaced. And South Pasadena has decided to limit its public outreach to avoid similar pushback.

With Election Day fast approaching, some Pinellas County municipalities are growing reluctant to tell residents how the controversial property-tax amendment could affect local services, fearing confrontations that have ranged from public shaming to reported personal threats against city officials.

If approved by voters Nov. 3, Amendment 3 would increase Florida's homestead property-tax exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 for non-school taxes — reducing the revenues that cities and counties rely on to pay for public safety, roads, libraries, parks and other services.

Some municipalities have warned that the revenue losses would force cuts to services — including police and fire — or eliminate some altogether. Largo has even drafted an alternative budget should the measure pass.

“The pushback that many cities have gotten when they have put things out — from both state officials and the public — has really shifted that for a lot of cities,” South Pasadena City Administrator Carley Lewis told commissioners during a recent workshop.

Cities under fire

In both Largo and Seminole, state Rep. Berny Jacques, R-Seminole, publicly accused local officials of using taxpayer resources to influence voters against Amendment 3.

State Rep. Berny Jacques, R-Seminole, accused Largo and Seminole officials of using taxpayer resources to influence voters against Amendment 3.Photo from Berny Jacques.

Jacques first challenged Largo in a Sept. 1 letter, accusing the city of presenting a one-sided view of the amendment by planning a public forum featuring former state Sen. Jeff Brandes, an outspoken critic of the proposal. Largo responded by inviting Jacques to participate in the forum.

Three weeks later, Jacques turned his attention to Seminole, where the city had posted an online alert directing residents to information about Amendment 3.

The webpage, first reported by The Pinellas Current, included a Pinellas County analysis of the amendment's potential financial impact, statements from organizations opposing the measure and news articles critical of the proposal.

Jacques fired off a Sept. 25 letter to Mayor Leslie Waters, accusing Seminole of using its official website to promote opposition to the amendment. He demanded that the material be removed and threatened to file a complaint with the Florida Elections Commission if the city failed to comply by Sept. 30.

At a special meeting that day, City Attorney Jay Daigneault warned council members that they faced an uncertain legal landscape and could be sued if they refused to remove the material.

“I don't think we've done anything wrong, but I don't think the taxpayers should have to go to court over this,” Council member Kadi Hendricks Tubbs said.

The council agreed to remove links to opposition statements and news articles while retaining financial analyses and other information about the amendment.

“All we're doing is providing information to our residents, so they can be more better informed when they go to the polls,” Vice Mayor Chris Burke said.

The backlash goes online

Jacques posted his letter to Facebook, where his criticism of Seminole drew both praise and pushback.

Some commenters applauded his intervention and accused local governments of wasting taxpayer money; others defended the cities' efforts to inform residents about the amendment's potential consequences.

Belleair Bluffs Mayor Chris Arbutine Sr. criticized state Rep. Berny Jacques for targeting municipalities that have warned residents about Amendment 3.Photo from City of Belleair Bluffs

Among the commenters was Belleair Bluffs Mayor Chris Arbutine Sr.

“All municipalities are required to have audits and by law a balanced budget,” he wrote, adding that municipal spending records are available to the public. “Everything has sky rocketed in price since Covid-19.”

Arbutine continued his criticism at the Oct. 19 Belleair Bluffs City Commission meeting.

“Has Largo recovered from Berny Jacques?” Arbutine asked. “He's out there slamming everybody. I don't know what he thinks he's doing by attacking the cities. I really don't understand it.”

Commissioners questioned Jacques' understanding of municipal budgeting and argued that the potential consequences of Amendment 3 were not a partisan issue but a matter of residents' quality of life.

City Administrator Debra Sullivan said the hostility surrounding Amendment 3 had escalated to personal threats. Referring to a city manager she knows, Sullivan told commissioners, “Her literal life was threatened.”

Transit agency targeted, too

Jacques’ online shaming of Largo and Seminole was a similar approach used by Pinellas County Commissioner Vince Nowicki to criticize the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority (PSTA).

Pinellas County Commissioner Vince Nowicki accused the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority of using taxpayer-funded communications to advocate against Amendment 3.Photo from Pinellas County.

In an Oct. 1 Facebook post, Nowicki accused the agency of using its website and social media to warn that Amendment 3 could lead to bus route eliminations, layoffs and other service cuts.

“Your tax dollars should never be used to influence your vote,” Nowicki wrote, accusing PSTA of engaging in taxpayer-funded advocacy.

He said he had called for the materials to be removed pending legal review and for related records to be preserved.

A PSTA spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment.

The line between public education and political advocacy can be difficult to draw because officials and residents do not always agree on what's best for their communities, said longtime political observer Darryl Paulson, an emeritus professor of government at the University of South Florida in St. Petersburg.

He pointed to the "Penny for Pinellas" 1-cent sales tax renewal campaigns as an example of how local governments have walked a tightrope between providing information and promoting a ballot measure.

Paulson said recent polls suggest support for Amendment 3 has “dissipated” and remains below the 60% needed for passage. He noted concerns about the proposal's potential effects on public safety, parks and other services.

“Even if you offer voters billions of dollars in tax cuts, they will turn it down if they do not think the cuts are justified,” he said.

A chilling effect

In South Pasadena, meanwhile, officials were wary of facing a similar public flogging.

"We saw what happened to some of our neighbors," Mayor Arthur Penny said at an Oct. 20 workshop.

Commissioners decided to scale back plans to inform residents about Amendment 3 before Election Day.

Lewis, the city administrator, said some municipalities were moving away from distributing information proactively and instead responding to residents who contacted them with questions.

“They've seen a really negative response that is almost inciting negativity to put out information rather than clarifying anything,” she said.

South Pasadena commissioners weighed whether to warn residents about potential service cuts, but worried that remaining silent could also draw criticism after the election.

Commissioners ultimately favored urging residents with questions to contact City Hall, rather than issuing detailed warnings about the amendment's potential impact.

“I am concerned about putting out any level of information,” Lewis said.

.

Sources & Notes

This story has been updated to include comments from University of South Florida emeritus professor Darryl Paulson.