Flock Flit: Coming to Belleair Beach?
After saying he'd move license plate cameras if county officials banned them, the Pinellas sheriff seeks permission to install two in Belleair Beach.
BELLEAIR BEACH — Last week, Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri told county commissioners that if they banned license plate-reading cameras on county roads, he would simply move them elsewhere.
"I'll just move them. Put them up somewhere else," he said.
Six days later, at a Nov. 2 City Council meeting, City Manager Kyle Riefler disclosed that the sheriff's office wants permission to install two cameras on city-owned property.
The request comes amid growing local and national opposition to the expanding network of automated license plate readers over concerns about privacy and government surveillance.
In August, Gov. Ron DeSantis ordered Flock license plate-reading cameras removed from the state highway system within 30 days. Some sheriff's offices, including Pasco County, subsequently announced they were ending their license plate reader programs.
At an Oct. 27 county commission meeting, commissioners considered a proposal by Commissioner Vince Nowicki to prohibit the cameras on county property and rights-of-way. The commission took no action, with several members favoring statewide regulations over a local ban.
Whether the proposed Belleair Beach cameras are replacements for cameras removed elsewhere or additions to the sheriff's existing network was unclear.
“Being that it is something that’s controversial, I would like the council’s opinion on whether you want to accept this within the city,” Riefler told council members.
Mayor Dave Gattis said the sheriff had “reached out” to him about the proposal and that he directed Gualtieri to send information on it to Riefler so it could be shared with the rest of the council.
Gattis said one camera would be placed at City Hall, facing the Belleair Causeway bridge. The other would be installed at Crossman Park, near the intersection of Causeway Boulevard and Gulf Boulevard.
Sheriff's office documents identify the park area as an alternative location for a camera monitoring westbound traffic. The documents also identify a potential location on nearby private property.
Gattis suggested the technology is already being used within the city, just not with fixed cameras.
“There’s always a patrol car on the other side of the bridge pointing in this direction,” he said. “There’s also one somewhere in Belleair Beach not doing anything, just sitting there. All they’re doing is monitoring cameras that are reporting license plates, is that correct?”
“I’m not aware exactly what they’re doing,” sheriff’s Sgt. Brian Hirshman responded.
Gattis said he was undecided and asked council members for feedback. Among the questions raised were why the sheriff's office needed cameras in Belleair Beach and how the collected information would be used.
Hirshman said patrol vehicles already have license plate readers but could not answer detailed questions about the proposed fixed cameras or the handling of their data.
“It’s a tough one,” council member Jody Shirley said. “Maybe it is something the city should look at, but look at carefully.”
Council member Frank Bankard was the only member to state a position.
“I have a big problem with this,” he said. “I think this is like an invasion of privacy. I don’t like criminals, but I mean, where do we stop?”
Bankard compared the technology to microchipping animals.
"Maybe we should start chipping the residents. Then we won't need beach umbrella tags," he said, alluding to neighboring Belleair Shore’s proposed permit program for umbrellas and other "sunshade structures."
In materials provided to the city, the sheriff's office defended automated license plate readers as a law enforcement tool that helps locate missing people, identify stolen vehicles and track down criminal suspects.
The agency said the cameras capture still photographs of passing vehicles and their license plates, along with the date, time and location, rather than continuously recording video. It also said officers must independently verify alerts before taking enforcement action and that access to stored information is subject to safeguards and auditing.
The documents did not state how long the sheriff's office retains license plate data or which agencies can access it.
Gattis urged council members to provide their views to Riefler, who would relay them to the sheriff's office.
Riefler told The Pinellas Current he expects the issue to be discussed further at an upcoming meeting.