74°Mostly Sunny

Saint Petersburg, FL 

The Pinellas Current

Independent news for Pinellas County

Support us

Commissioner's Partner Faces Removal

A dispute over pension finances puts a trustee's close relationship with a South Pasadena commissioner under scrutiny — and his position in jeopardy.

The Pinellas Current@pinellascurrent· Saint Petersburg, FLByCarlos Moncada
South Pasadena City Hall, where commissioners are seeking to remove a trustee from the city's firefighters' pension board amid a dispute over the fund's financial management.Photo from City of South Pasadena.

SOUTH PASADENA — A pension board member described as the partner of a city commissioner may be removed from his position, but not necessarily because of their relationship.

Richard O'Connor, a retired accountant, attorney and chief financial officer, faces possible removal from the city's firefighters' pension board amid disagreements over his efforts to change how the underfunded retirement plan's finances are managed.

During a Nov. 3 workshop, city officials raised concerns about O'Connor's close relationship with the commissioner, saying it created the appearance of a conflict of interest. Officials did not name the commissioner, but The Pinellas Current identified her as Lynda Thompson through records of previous commission meetings.

A Relationship Already Known

The nature of the relationship could not be independently confirmed, but its existence was no secret to city staff or the other commissioners.

At a February 2025 meeting, Thompson recused herself from voting on O'Connor's reappointment and the appointment of another trustee because of what the minutes described as "a personal relationship with one of the appointees."

It wasn't the first time the relationship had come up.

In May 2024, Thompson abstained from voting on O'Connor's appointment to the city's Auditor Selection Committee after the city clerk advised that two commissioners had personal relationships with appointees, records show. The remaining four commissioners unanimously approved O'Connor's appointment.

South Pasadena Mayor Arthur Penny has defended the city's efforts to remove a firefighters' pension board trustee amid disagreements over management of the underfunded pension plan.Photo from City of South Pasadena.

Yet at the workshop commissioners and staff expressed unease about O'Connor's relationship with Thompson and raised concerns about his continued service on the pension board.

“I just think that it’s causing a disruption and a problem with staff and other members on the pension board,” Mayor Arthur Penny said. “I do think we should replace our representative at this point.”

Much of the workshop discussion focused on what commissioners described as O'Connor's efforts to change financial assumptions used to calculate the pension fund's liabilities as well as the board's actuarial firm.

Commissioners ultimately agreed to place his removal on the agenda for a formal vote Nov. 10.

A Dispute Over Pension Finances

The controversy comes as South Pasadena's firefighters' pension fund is about 67% funded, below the 80% to 85% level city officials say it should reach.

"We're told it's not a crisis," City Administrator Carley Lewis told commissioners. "It's not a sky-is-falling situation. But it is at the lower end. That's probably not an ideal place to be leaving it, in the 60s."

At the Oct. 21 pension board quarterly meeting, trustees discussed lowering the fund's assumed annual investment return. That would mean projecting less investment income in future years, potentially requiring the city to contribute more money to cover promised retirement benefits.

The board also considered soliciting proposals from actuarial firms, a move that could lead to replacing its current provider, St. Petersburg-based Foster & Foster.

City officials questioned the timing of those proposals, arguing that the pension board should wait for updated financial calculations reflecting the fund's investment performance.

During the workshop, Vice Mayor Thomas B. Reid said one trustee, presumably O'Connor, was “extremely aggressive” in pushing to lower the fund's assumed interest rate, despite recommendations to wait for additional actuarial information.

Commissioner Gail M. Neidinger questioned the effort to solicit proposals from other firms.

“Do we really need to change the actuary? My feeling is no," she said. "They’ve been doing a decent job for us for a long time. I thought that was a little far-reaching.”

Officials described the pension board meeting, which some commissioners had viewed, as “painful” and "uncomfortable."

“The meeting was hijacked,” Reid said. “That’s how I looked at it.”

“It was just push push push,” Neidinger said of the proposed changes.

Beyond the financial disagreements, City Attorney Kristen Gray raised concerns about O'Connor's relationship with Thompson.

South Pasadena officials are seeking to remove a firefighters' pension board trustee whose relationship with Commissioner Lynda Thompson has become a point of concern.Photo from City of South Pasadena.

"I want to be very clear this is not an illegal conflict," Gray said. "The commission did nothing wrong in appointing this member. And there’s nothing wrong with this member currently sitting on the board.”

Nevertheless, Gray said city staff believes the relationship creates the appearance of a conflict because members of the public and other pension trustees "are having trouble distinguishing between the independent perspective of the sitting pension board member and the current sitting commissioner."

Gray said the concern was especially noteworthy because Thompson oversees the city's Public Safety Department, which includes the fire department.

O'Connor was originally appointed in August 2022, records show. His current two-year term expires in February 2027.

Thompson was absent from the Election Day workshop. In response to a request for comment, she said she had been out following surgery and referred questions to the city. Attempts to reach O'Connor were unsuccessful.

O'Connor is one of two resident members on the five-member pension board. Gray told commissioners they have broad discretion to remove those appointees without establishing cause.

Commissioners agreed the pension fund needs more money, but worried that lowering its expected investment returns could leave the city having to pay more.

Penny suggested the city gradually increase its contributions to strengthen the fund. But he warned that would become more difficult if voters approved Amendment 3, which would increase homestead property-tax exemptions and reduce revenue available to cities for services such as police and fire protection.

“The polls say it’s not going to pass, but you never know,” the mayor said. “I’ll believe it tonight at 6 or 7 o’clock.”

The amendment passed later that day.