Seminole Sues First, Asks Later
Council signs off on Halloween concert lawsuit after the fact, leaving unresolved whether prior approval was needed.
SEMINOLE — Sometimes it's easier to ask for permission after the fact.
That's essentially what happened when the City Council voted Nov. 10 to ratify a lawsuit its attorney had already filed against a couple over concerts held at their waterfront home.
City Attorney Jay Daigneault acknowledged some legal uncertainty about whether he needed council approval before filing the lawsuit Oct. 29 against Scott and Judy McGehee, of 9049 Baywood Park Dr.
The question of whether advance approval was required was raised by The Pinellas Current.
"Under your charter, one can make a cogent argument that I need your permission in advance to file a lawsuit on your behalf," Daigneault told council members.
But he said an equally reasonable argument could be made that he could file the lawsuit first and obtain formal council approval afterward.
Daigneault said he consulted City Manager Ann Toney-Deal before filing suit and seeking an emergency injunction to stop two concerts scheduled for Halloween weekend at the McGehee property, advertised as Live on the Bayou.
Daigneault previously told The Pinellas Current that he consulted council members individually before filing the lawsuit. Circuit Judge Evan Frayman granted the temporary injunction Oct. 30, and that day's concert was moved to nearby Seminole Lake Country Club.
Concerns about unpermitted construction and potential fire hazards at the McGehee property prompted the action, he said. Mayor Leslie Waters also worried about the safety of young trick-or-treaters amid the additional traffic and street parking expected from the concerts.
"I think that my duty to act as your legal advisor compelled my conduct and compelled the filing of the lawsuit," Daigneault said.
Vice Mayor Chris Burke moved to ratify the lawsuit, Councilor Ray Beliveau seconded, and the council approved it with little discussion.
The injunction remains in effect, and the lawsuit is pending.